Short answer: Sometimes, yes. Signing an arbitration agreement doesn’t always mean your case has to go to private arbitration. Two published California appeals decisions from November 2026 refused to enforce arbitration agreements: one because the agreement was too one-sided, and one because the worker’s claims involved harassment based on her gender and pregnancy. Whether either ruling helps you depends on your agreement and your facts.
Last updated: November 19, 2026.
Key takeaways
- An arbitration agreement is a contract, and California courts can refuse to enforce one that is unconscionable, meaning unfair in how it was presented and one-sided in its terms.
- In Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions (November 13, 2026), a Los Angeles appeals court refused to enforce an arbitration agreement tucked into a call-center worker’s roughly 100-page new hire packet. The court found it reached claims unrelated to her job, had no end date, and was one-sided in favor of the company and a long list of related people and entities.
- In Doe v. The Maybourne Beverly Hills Operator (November 17, 2026), another Los Angeles appeals panel held that a federal law protecting sexual harassment claims from forced arbitration can also cover harassment based on gender or pregnancy under California law. It isn’t limited to sexual or lewd conduct.
- These rulings are new and fact-specific. Many arbitration agreements are still enforced, and either decision could be reviewed by a higher court.
- If your employer is trying to move your case into arbitration, it may be worth having the agreement and your claims reviewed early.
What is an arbitration agreement, and why does it matter?
An arbitration agreement says that disputes with your employer will be decided by a private arbitrator instead of a judge or jury in a public courtroom. Many workers sign one without noticing. It’s often a few pages buried in onboarding paperwork, next to the tax forms and the handbook acknowledgment.
It matters because arbitration usually happens in private, and agreements often bar class actions. When a worker files a lawsuit, the employer may ask the court to “compel arbitration,” which means to move the case out of court. The two new decisions both started that way, and in both, the employer lost.
What happened in the call-center case?
According to the opinion, a customer service call-center company hired a worker in February 2023 and gave her an approximately 100-page new hire packet. An arbitration agreement and a confidentiality agreement were in the middle of it. She understood she had to sign them to be hired. She worked there until April 2023 and later filed a class action alleging minimum wage, overtime, and meal and rest break violations, among other claims. (Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, B346763)
The company moved to compel arbitration. The trial court said no, and on November 13, 2026, the Court of Appeal affirmed in a published 2–1 decision.
Why wouldn’t the court enforce it?
California courts look at two things: how the agreement was presented (procedural unconscionability) and how fair its terms are (substantive unconscionability). The more one-sided the terms, the less unfairness in the signing process is needed. The court relied on the California Supreme Court’s framework in Ramirez v. Charter Communications (2024).
Here, the court found only a low degree of unfairness in how the agreement was presented. It was a take-it-or-leave-it contract, but there was no evidence she was rushed or kept from reviewing it. What decided the case were the terms. The court found the agreement:
- Reached far beyond the job. It covered claims “whether or not” they arose out of her employment.
- Had no end date. It survived the end of her employment and could only be revoked in a writing signed by all of the company’s partners and her.
- Was one-sided. It defined “the Company” to include past and present partners, officers, directors, employees, affiliates, and others. Those people and entities could force her to arbitrate her claims against them, but she had no matching right to force their claims against her into arbitration.
- Was paired with an unfair confidentiality agreement. The court read the two together. It found the confidentiality agreement’s injunction clause, which let the company skip proving irreparable harm, and its one-year ban on soliciting coworkers also unconscionable.
The company asked the court to just cross out the bad parts. The court refused. It said fixing the agreement would mean rewriting it, which courts can’t do, and that the unfairness “permeates” the agreement. One justice dissented, arguing the majority’s approach conflicts with federal arbitration law.
What happened in the Beverly Hills hotel case?
In the second case, a longtime guest reception manager at a Beverly Hills luxury hotel had signed an arbitration agreement in June 2020. After she was fired in January 2024, she sued under California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). Her claims included harassment based on sex, gender, and pregnancy, plus discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination. (Doe v. The Maybourne Beverly Hills Operator, LLC, B341400)
As the opinion describes her complaint, she was told after disclosing her pregnancy that she would not be able to be “a career woman once she had children.” She applied for a promotion, was never interviewed, and the job went to a man. A regional director later told her “her first priority would always be her children” and suggested she not ask for a raise. Shortly after she pushed for fair pay, she was accused, falsely by her account, of a sexual relationship with a coworker, then suspended and fired. These are her allegations, and no one has decided whether they’re true.
The hotel argued the federal law protecting harassment claims from forced arbitration only applies to sexual misconduct, not to gender or pregnancy harassment. The court disagreed.
What is the federal law that protects harassment claims?
The Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 was signed into law on March 3, 2022. It says that, if the person bringing a sexual harassment or sexual assault dispute chooses, a pre-dispute arbitration agreement or class or collective action waiver is not “valid or enforceable” for a case that “relates to” that dispute. A court decides whether the law applies, not an arbitrator. (9 U.S.C. § 402) It applies to disputes or claims that arise or accrue on or after March 3, 2022.
The law defines a “sexual harassment dispute” by looking to whether the conduct is alleged to be sexual harassment under applicable federal, tribal, or state law. (9 U.S.C. § 401)
Why does California law make a difference here?
California defines harassment “because of sex” broadly. FEHA says it “includes sexual harassment, gender harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions,” and that harassing conduct “need not be motivated by sexual desire.” (Gov. Code § 12940(j)(4)(C)) FEHA’s definition of “sex” also includes pregnancy and gender. (Gov. Code § 12926(r))
Because the federal law points to state law, the court looked to FEHA’s definition. It held that the federal protection is “not limited to allegations of lewd or lascivious behavior.” It then found that her complaint plausibly alleged a hostile work environment based on gender or pregnancy. The court affirmed the order keeping the entire case in court, not just the harassment claim.
The court was careful to say that whoever decides the facts might still find the conduct wasn’t severe or pervasive enough. The ruling decided where the case is heard, not who wins.
Does this mean my arbitration agreement is invalid?
Not necessarily. Here is what these cases do and don’t mean:
| If your situation looks like this… | What these rulings suggest |
|---|---|
| The agreement covers claims “whether or not” related to your job, never ends, or protects a long list of company people and entities without giving you the same rights | It may be worth a close look under Bennett. Courts look at the exact wording and the whole package you signed. |
| You’re bringing a FEHA claim for sexual, gender, or pregnancy harassment | Federal law may let you choose to keep the case in court, depending on your complaint and when the dispute arose. |
| Your claims are about wages, breaks, or discrimination with no harassment, and the agreement is fairly balanced | Arbitration may still be enforced. Every agreement and case is different. |
| You were required to sign arbitration as a condition of the job, and federal arbitration law doesn’t govern the agreement | California’s Labor Code § 432.6 may matter. See our explainer on the Molina ruling. |
What should I do if I signed one?
- Find your copy. Look through your onboarding documents, handbook acknowledgments, and any HR portal. Ask HR for a copy in writing if you can’t find it.
- Keep the whole packet. In Bennett, the court read the arbitration agreement together with a separate confidentiality agreement. Other documents may matter too.
- Write down what happened. Note dates, names, and exact comments, especially anything about your gender, pregnancy, or family responsibilities.
- Don’t assume you have no options. Being told “you signed arbitration” isn’t the final word. A court may decide whether the agreement can be enforced.
- Watch your deadlines. For harassment and discrimination claims under FEHA, the Civil Rights Department says that in employment cases you must submit an intake form within three years of the date you were last harmed, and that you need a Right-to-Sue notice from CRD before filing your own lawsuit. (CRD complaint process) Other deadlines can apply after that, so it’s best not to wait.
Related reading
If you were pushed into arbitration as part of hiring, our post on the Molina ruling and forced arbitration under Labor Code § 432.6 explains a separate protection. For a newer form of workplace harassment, see when a coworker’s deepfake can be harassment in California. And since the call-center case involved break claims, our guide to missed meal and rest breaks in California may help. You can also learn more about sexual harassment, hostile work environments, and pregnancy discrimination.
Frequently asked questions
Can my employer make me sign an arbitration agreement to get hired in California?
It depends. California’s Labor Code § 432.6 restricts requiring arbitration as a condition of employment, but federal courts have held that it is preempted when federal arbitration law governs the agreement. In both of these new cases, the agreement was treated as governed by federal arbitration law. Even then, an agreement can still be challenged as unconscionable, as in Bennett.
Does the federal harassment arbitration law cover pregnancy harassment?
According to the Maybourne decision, it can, when a worker brings a FEHA harassment claim, because California defines harassment “because of sex” to include gender harassment and harassment based on pregnancy. The case is new, and other courts may see it differently.
If one of my claims is harassment, does my whole case stay in court?
In Maybourne, the court affirmed denying arbitration for the entire case, including the discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination claims. How a court treats a mixed case may depend on the facts and how closely the other claims relate to the harassment.
Is it too late to challenge the agreement if I already signed it?
Signing is what makes it a contract, but a court can still decide that a signed agreement is unenforceable. Both workers in these cases had signed. The issue usually comes up when the employer asks the court to compel arbitration.
Do I have to pay for arbitration?
In the Bennett agreement, the company agreed to pay the arbitrator’s fees “to the full extent required by law.” Terms vary, so check your agreement or have it reviewed.
Talk to MAGISA LAW about your situation
If you signed an arbitration agreement and think your employer mistreated you, harassed you, or didn’t pay you correctly, you don’t have to sort out the fine print alone. MAGISA LAW represents employees in Glendale and across the Los Angeles area. Contact us for a free, confidential consultation to talk about your specific situation.
This post is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every situation is different, and the law can change.